Twitter You Tube Facebook Autobodynews Linked In

Friday, 30 May 2014 00:00

Attorney Says Non-Compete Agreements in Arizona Follow the Goldilocks Principle: Too Broad and Too Narrow

An Arizona attorney, Lindsay G. Leavitt, with Jennings, Strouss & Salmon, PLC, says that non-compete agreements under Arizona law follow a “Goldilocks principle”: some are too broad, some are too narrow, and some are just right.

For the full text of Mr. Leavitt's blog go to

"Although Arizona law recognizes the need to protect legitimate business interests, it also hesitates to restrict individuals from pursuing their chosen careers. A well-drafted non-compete agreement can successfully balance the interests of both the employer and employee.

"A non-compete agreement is unreasonable and will not be enforced if (1) the restraint is greater than necessary to protect the employer’s legitimate interest; or (2) that interest is outweighed by the hardship to the employee and the likely injury to the public.


"In October 2013, the Arizona Court of Appeals held that a non-compete agreement between a public relations company and its former president Ann Noder was over-broad and therefore unenforceable. Orca Communications Unlimited LLC versus Noder, 233 Ariz. 411, 314 P.3d 89 (App. 2013). The agreement prohibited Noder from directly or indirectly advertising, soliciting, or providing “conflicting services” within a “restricted territory” for eighteen months after her employment had ended. The court found that the restrictive covenants protected more than Orca’s legitimate business interests because it prevented Noder from pursuing any type of work in the public relations industry, even work that would be based on her skill and talents and not merely confidential information or customer relationships. The court refused to rewrite the provisions to make them enforceable, thus freeing Noder to immediately compete against her former employer.

"A valid non-compete agreement cannot be copied and pasted from a preexisting template. Each industry and business has unique circumstances and interests that must be considered when drafting an effective and enforceable non-compete agreement.

"Seeking the advice of competent legal counsel can give employers the confidence to avoid the trial and error method of Goldilocks—ensuring that their non-compete agreements will be 'just right.' "

As always, consult a qualified attorney before acting on any news report that may have legal repercussions.

Read 416 times